top of page

The Fire Decision That's Hardest to Fix Later: In Conversation with Jay Tang

Writer: Rebeka Zubac
Rebeka Zubac
15 hours ago
5 min read

Before Jay Tang designed fire protection systems, he designed structures. Now our Senior Fire Services Engineer, Jay sat down with us to talk about where fire services design goes right or wrong, from the tank that's hardest to fit in late to the passive fire details that most often go wrong on site.

Jay is an FPAS Accredited Fire System Designer with more than five years in the fire protection industry, covering wet, dry and passive fire. Since joining Goldfish & Bay in 2023, he has specialised in sprinkler, hydrant and detection system design and Revit modelling, on projects including St Vincent's Hospital's O'Brien Centre in Darlinghurst, Precinct 75 in St Peters, Tallawong Station Precinct South at Rouse Hill and the NextSense Centre of Excellence.

Fire engineer or fire services engineer?

It's the question people get wrong all the time, so we started there. "Fire engineers work on a broader fire safety strategy, while fire services engineers focus on the design of the physical fire protection systems," Jay explains. Fire services engineers design to the Australian Standards, and when something can't be addressed through a Deemed to Satisfy (DTS) solution, the fire engineer can give them a helping hand.

The decision that hurts most if it's made late

Booster and pump room locations, tank sizes and riser space all need early attention. For Jay, one item comes first.

"Pipework can generally be modified or rerouted at a later stage, whereas if the fire tank is overlooked during design, it can be extremely difficult to find a suitable space to accommodate it once construction is underway."

His approach is to resolve anything with significant structural implications or high costs as early as possible, to avoid major design changes and costly variations later in the project.

What a structural engineer sees in fire design

Before moving into fire protection, Jay spent six years in Shanghai as a structural engineer and assistant construction manager, after studying civil engineering at Tongji University and UNSW. When he started in fire, it gave him a head start over other graduates: he could already read structural drawings like concrete setout plans, and he understood structural layouts and building components.

It also gave him a different perspective on constructability. "I don't just look at whether a system complies with the relevant Australian Standards. I also consider whether the pipelines or fire tank are designed reasonably to minimise the impact on the structural components." In early design, that means keeping risers out of thick slabs and deep beams, and setting pipework levels so they stay clear of areas with dense reinforcing bars.

Passive fire: why the product name isn't enough

Passive fire is one of Jay's specialties, and penetrations through fire rated walls and floors get a lot of attention in NSW. His starting point might surprise people: "Service penetrations through fire rated walls and floors are unavoidable, and there is nothing inherently wrong with having them."

The critical issue is making sure every penetration is properly fire stopped, so the wall or floor keeps its required fire resistance. The standards don't prescribe a specific fire stopping method for every scenario. Instead, manufacturers test and assess their own products, and the approved installation details and limitations are set out in their technical data sheets and test reports. Builders need to understand those documents to select and install the right product for each penetration type and site condition.

"Simply choosing a fire sealant or fire collar based on its product name is not sufficient. The proposed installation must be consistent with the tested and approved system."

The good news, Jay says, is that awareness of passive fire protection is gradually improving across the industry. As builders, contractors and other stakeholders understand the basic principles better, he expects to see fewer fire stopping defects and better installation quality overall.

The defect he sees most often on site

It isn't dramatic, and that's the point. The most common defect Jay finds during site inspections is incorrect or inadequate installation of pipe hangers. Often the details aren't clearly documented on the design drawings, or even the shop drawings, and with site constraints and tight programs they're easy to overlook.

"Such non compliances will not always impact the system performance immediately, however long term durability could be a concern." That's why the team works to identify them during site inspections, so they can be fixed early and clients avoid unnecessary rework and extra cost.

When the warehouse changes but the sprinklers don't

For Jay, this is one of the biggest challenges in warehouse fire protection. A sprinkler system is designed around an assumed storage arrangement and commodity classification at one point in time, but how the warehouse is actually used can change significantly over its life.

"As a designer, we cannot consider all the potential scenarios, as this would significantly increase the cost." Building owners and tenants need to understand the limitations of their existing system, rather than assuming it will suit whatever is stored there. If significant changes are planned, it falls on them to engage engineers to review the system.

AS 1851 maintenance in NSW

NSW building owners now have to maintain their fire safety measures to AS 1851, and accredited certification of newly installed systems is on its way. Jay doesn't expect this to change design much, although designers will need to give more thought to making future maintenance easier.

He does see it as significant for the fire protection industry. "Maintenance is no longer simply a matter of engaging a contractor to conduct periodic inspections. There is now a defined regulatory framework around the frequency, procedures and records of maintenance activities."

Sprinklers in carparks

The ABCB has proposed sprinkler protection for carparks with more than 40 car spaces and for car stackers, largely because of electric vehicles and larger vehicles. Jay's view is clear: he thinks it's the right call.

How Revit changed fire services design

Jay says Revit has transformed the way building services are designed and coordinated. The deliverables are essentially the same as a traditional CAD project. The difference is that Revit shows equipment and services at their actual dimensions rather than as simplified symbols, which significantly improves coordination with the structure and other services, and makes the design easier for everyone to understand.

He finds it most useful in confined spaces like fire pump rooms and booster assembly enclosures, where clearances are critical. "With simplified CAD layouts, we could sometimes overlook clearance issues because the equipment was not represented in its actual dimensions. With Revit, we can examine the model in 3D, check clearances from different angles and identify potential clashes before construction begins."

What stood out

Across every answer, Jay's focus was the same: thinking beyond compliance. About the structure the services have to fit around, about how systems will actually be installed, and about how a building will be used long after handover.

Thanks for the chat, Jay! We appreciate you sharing your experience, and the care you bring to every project at Goldfish & Bay.

FEATURED ARTICLE

LATEST ARTICLES

NEVER MISS A NEW POST

  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
bottom of page